Since I was probably derailing the HAIM thread too much and should leave those who enjoy them in peace, I thought maybe starting this thread would be more productive. Let's try to make it more than just "this film is overrated/underrated", etc. Of course, "unpopular" doesn't just mean negative.
I'll start with some (the first one I've voiced ad nauseam):
-Enough with the music videos, please. At least for a while.
-April Grace gives the best performance in Magnolia.
-I never really got the love for the Fiona Apple relationship and it's surprising that all these years later, people still put them on a pedestal.
-I wish he'd be willing to direct other people's scripts. I wonder if you told him in 1997 that in 2020 that he'd only have made 8 films what his response would be.