Tarantino rankings

[Pubrick]

Reservoir Dogs - * * * *
Pulp Fiction - * * * *
Jackie Brown - * * * *
Kill Bill - * * * *

I'd give all four of them ****

Kill Bill Vol 1 *** 1/2

Make that a 4, I wasn't thinking straight.

fyags.

[Weak2ndAct]

I think of Tarantino movies like children.  You can say you love them all equally, but deep down, there are favorites.  Personally, I'm a Jackie Brown man.  I dig Quentin's assessment that it's a 'hang out' movie.

[brockly]

Jackie Brown is his best, but Pulp is just a genuine favourite. Its got the characters, the structure, the originality, the dialogue and the soundtrack that make it so much.... fun.

dogs *
pulp *
jack *
killb *

*bows down and grasps P's feet*

I'm not worthy!

[Sleuth]

dogs *
pulp *
jack *
killb *

i'm a man.

You sure feel like one

[ono]

Reservoir Dogs ***½
Pulp Fiction ****+
Jackie Brown ****
Kill Bill ***½

I think I really overrated Kill Bill when it came out (problem I have with a lot of films because of hype, excitement, whatever), but looking back on it, it really is an exercise of style over substance.  Still, it's a good one.  Pulp Fiction is just gold, and Jackie Brown is excellent as well.  Reservoir Dogs is really stylized for a film with such a low budget as well, and I like Ebert's criticism of it, even though I like the film more than he did: that characters in such dire situations wouldn't do as much talking (as the Tim Roth character does), and perhaps more should be done with his characters instead of just talking.

[Gloria]

Reservior Dogs *** (Michael Madsen and the conversation about color names were my favorite things about this movie)
Pulp Fiction *** 1/2 (Very interesting plot and it captivated me the whole way through.)
Jackie Brown ****  (most underrated, smart and best film)
Kill Bill vol. 1 *** (fluff compared to his earlier works, but had enough enjoyable style and energy to boost my rating to 3 stars)

[NEON MERCURY]

R.D.***

P.F.***1/2

J.B.****

K.B.V.one***

[nix]

I think they all deserve four stars so I'll list them in order of favorites:

1. Pulp Fiction

2. Jackie Brown

3. Reservoir Dogs

4. Kill Bill

[©brad]

[nix]

:2gunfire:

[j_scott_stroup04]

Reservoir Dogs- ****

Pulp Fiction- ****

Jackie Brown-***1/2

Kill Bill Vol. 1- ****

I love that muthafucker!
The only other person who can match that with their first four films is PTA:

Hard Eight- ***1/2
Boogie Nights- ****
Magnolia- ****
Punch-Drunk Love- ****

Some people are getting close...like Wes Anderson

Bottle Rocket- ***1/2
Rushmore- ****
Royal Tenenbaums- ***1/2

Maybe after he makes another film he'll rank up there with those two for best four film starts of the past two decades, if not all time.

[SoNowThen]

Reservoir Dogs: *** 1/2
Pulp Fiction: *** 1/2
Jackie Brown: ****
KB: ****


...oh what the hell

Hard Eight: ***
Boogie Nights: ****
Magnolia: *********************************************
PDL: ** 1/2


Bottle Rocket: **
Rushmore: ****
The Royal Tenenbaums: *** 1/2

[ElPandaRoyal]

Reservoir Dogs - *** 1/2
Pulp Fiction - ****
Jackie Brown - ****
Kill Bill - ****

-----

Hard Eight - *** 1/2
Boogie Nights - *** 1/2
Magnolia - ****
Punch-Drunk Love - ****

-----

Bottle Rocket - ***
Rushmore - *** 1/2
The Royal Tenenbaums - ****

-----

Pay It Forward - 0

[SHAFTR]

Fine

PTA

Hard Eight: **1/2
Boogie Nights: ****
Magnolia: ***1/2
Punch-Drunk Love:  ****

Wes Anderson

Bottle Rocket: **1/2
Rushmore:  ****
The Royal Tenenbaums: ****

I'll continue it

Spike Jonze

Being John Malkovich: ***
Adaptation: ***1/2

[Gold Trumpet]

PTA.......Wes Anderson........Spike Jonze.

someone lock this thread.