Xixax Film Forum

Film Discussion => News and Theory => Topic started by: 1976 on October 12, 2003, 07:06:30 AM

Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: 1976 on October 12, 2003, 07:06:30 AM
"A Hundred Years Of Solitude"

Actually, this novel would probably be better served as an HBO mini-series since it spans several generations and features so many main characters that it probably couldn't all be covered in one feature film. But I could see a talented director creating a 210 minute Epic which might capture the overall theme of the novel.

"The Da Vinci Code"

I hear this one is already in pre-production, but I have the feeling they will emphasize the international thriller/action aspects of the novel (in other words, a Tom Clancy clone starring Harrison Ford) rather than the conspiracy and religious aspects which made the book fascinating. This novel should be made in an Oliver Stone "JFK" style and really go in depth into the heart of the conspiracy. It would be quite controversial (since it basically attempts to expose Christianity as a fraud.)
Title: Re: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: MacGuffin on October 12, 2003, 07:26:08 AM
Quote from: Shadow Boxin""The Da Vinci Code"

I hear this one is already in pre-production, but I have the feeling they will emphasize the international thriller/action aspects of the novel (in other words, a Tom Clancy clone starring Harrison Ford) rather than the conspiracy and religious aspects which made the book fascinating. This novel should be made in an Oliver Stone "JFK" style and really go in depth into the heart of the conspiracy. It would be quite controversial (since it basically attempts to expose Christianity as a fraud.)

http://xixax.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=263&start=30
Title: ...
Post by: 1976 on October 12, 2003, 07:47:15 AM
Well, Ron Howard wouldn't have been my first choice, but I think he'll take the subject matter serious enough to make a sincere adaptation.
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: ***beady*** on October 12, 2003, 08:02:23 AM
I think one of the Terry Pratchets would be good.
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: cine on October 12, 2003, 10:56:34 AM
Quote from: ***beady***I think one of the Terry Pratchets would be good.

Yeah, and they'd gain an amazing cult status too.
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: Ernie on October 12, 2003, 12:01:59 PM
I want Tim Burton to do "Geek Love" like I heard he was going to and I wanna do "Truck" by the same author. I also might do "Sick Puppy" by Carl Hiaasen.
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: Find Your Magali on October 12, 2003, 12:08:39 PM
I'd like to see some of Dan Simmons' horror novels on the big screen.

Carrion Comfort is my favorite, but it would need a bigger budget to be done right, I think.

I'd love to see Summer of Night, and the set design for the creepy old school.

Song of Kali could be a creepy, creepy thriller.
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: Raikus on October 12, 2003, 02:27:01 PM
My ultimate novel to cinema dream... The Dark Tower series.

But done well. Like, PJ well.
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: ***beady*** on October 12, 2003, 03:30:49 PM
Hell yeah! Pj's done them fantasticaly.

I would also like to see any of the Edgar Alan Poe stories turned into films, or short films like the Twilight Zones.

Robin Jarvis any of his. But, I think that would have to be done cartoon style.

Eric Idle, 'Road to Mars', would be good.

'The Cigarette girl', by Carol Wolper I reckon would do quite well.

And I think there is some sort of film or some programme series made of the 'K-PAX' books by Gene Brewer. Haven't got round to wacthing them yet, but the books are brilliant!
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: ᾦɐļᵲʊʂ on October 12, 2003, 03:38:08 PM
I think it has been made into a movie, but I'd love to see a newer Catcher In The Rye done by the Coen Brothers.

Davinci Code should be done by Lynch, because something so serious should be cryptic like that.

Helter Skelter should be made into a movie, as well.  I'd like to see either Lynch or Burton get their hands on it for the dark twist.  (Like a story about Manson needs a twist, let alone a dark one)
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: MacGuffin on October 12, 2003, 09:10:23 PM
Quote from: Walrus, KooKookajoobI think it has been made into a movie, but I'd love to see a newer Catcher In The Rye done by the Coen Brothers.

It's never been made into a movie. Salinger won't release the rights and vows never to do so.

Quote from: Walrus, KooKookajoobHelter Skelter should be made into a movie, as well.  I'd like to see either Lynch or Burton get their hands on it for the dark twist.  (Like a story about Manson needs a twist, let alone a dark one)

It's already been made as an awesome mini-series, but I heard word somewhere that they were thinking about doing a feature.
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: ᾦɐļᵲʊʂ on October 12, 2003, 09:17:06 PM
Quote from: MacGuffin
Quote from: Walrus, KooKookajoobI think it has been made into a movie, but I'd love to see a newer Catcher In The Rye done by the Coen Brothers.

It's never been made into a movie. Salinger won't release the rights and vows never to do so.

That's respectable
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: Catcus Mack on October 12, 2003, 11:01:40 PM
These books are favourites of mine when i was a kid and have always wanted movies of them.

Sideways Stories from Wayside School

This Island Isn't Big Enough For The Four Of Us

My Babysitter is a Vampire

Stinky Stanley
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: Gamblour. on October 12, 2003, 11:31:01 PM
When (and I don't mean if) I became a great film-maker, I'd love to do Brave New World and the Stranger, because as I read them a few months ago, I thought they would be great as movies. I know they've been adapted before, Mastroianni was in a '67 version of the Stranger, haven't seen it but sounds like a good casting choice for Mersault. Today, I would have Adrien Brody, he seems perfect. BNW hasn't been made but on TV. These would be great movies.

Speaking of Catcher in the Rye, there's a load of similarities between it and Taxi Driver (which I'm sure has been talked about somewhere here before). That's a good substitute until Rye goes public domain in a hundred years (or whenever).

Also, just remembered that I read M. Night Shyamalan wants to adapt Life of Pi. I need to read that book, it's just gathering dust.
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: Alethia on October 12, 2003, 11:41:21 PM
gone with the wind
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: bonanzataz on October 12, 2003, 11:47:58 PM
errr... didn't i just make this thread 2 weeks ago?
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: coffeebeetle on October 13, 2003, 08:28:38 AM
Sex and Sunsets by Tim Sandlin  (starring Robert Downey Jr. and Elisabeth Shue)
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: Teen Wolf on October 13, 2003, 12:11:10 PM
I want a talented director to do Moby Dick. I know John Huston did it way back when, but I'd love to see someone else have a go at it.
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: ShanghaiOrange on October 13, 2003, 12:31:09 PM
Tarantino's Moby Dick, starring Harvey Kietel as Ahab and Sam Jackson as Queequeg.

Queequeg: "Why does my black as have to be chasing around some cracker whale?"
Ahab: "Motherfucking whale ate my goddamn arm, that's why!"
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: Cecil on October 13, 2003, 07:19:45 PM
i want ghostboy to adapt and shoot "heavier than heaven"
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: NEON MERCURY on October 13, 2003, 10:49:03 PM
..what a bout "See Spot Run"..i would like to see that into a short film...
..but maybe the reason no-one has trried it is b/c the pure essence of the novel is ambigious.....
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: snaporaz on October 14, 2003, 02:32:48 PM
it's already in pre-production, but i can't wait for glamorama.

and speaking of ellis, american psycho could have been alot better. so, i guess i'd like to see it made. again. and better.

also, i'd like to see the stranger beside me, but without the ann rule narrative. however, i think it's already been done. for television. "american nightmare" is a pretty cool title.  :oops:

i don't read much.  :(
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: godardian on October 14, 2003, 05:13:52 PM
Quote from: snaporaz

and speaking of ellis, american psycho could have been alot better. so, i guess i'd like to see it made. again. and better.

I thought it was a fine film, one of my favorites of the year. I can't wait for Mary Harron's next... she was involved in The Weather Underground, apparently.

Anyone seen the movie of Play it as it Lays?
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: pookiethecat on October 14, 2003, 06:20:23 PM
Quote from: godardian
Quote from: snaporaz

and speaking of ellis, american psycho could have been alot better. so, i guess i'd like to see it made. again. and better.

I thought it was a fine film, one of my favorites of the year. I can't wait for Mary Harron's next

same here...  and i thought it was awesome how harron juxtaposed satire and horror.  great performances.  funny and unsettling in all the right ways.  

in keeping topic with the thread, i'd like to see "the autograph man" by zadie smith adapted to the big screen by mike leigh.
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: Gold Trumpet on October 14, 2003, 06:56:38 PM
To keep with my usual self, I didn't like American Pyscho (movie) at all. The dialogue explained everything and left little mystery to anything at all the killer may have been feeling. The rationalization is that the killer and his story encompasses the feeling of spirit on modern day Wall Street in all its drive and ambition, but if gone awry. I don't see the intention for that, though. General story of man with drive and pushed to pyschosis that he kills to meet pleasures not found elsewhere. The fact that he works on Wall Street and such is only thing that is contemporary about him. And the ending, well, it gets a 10 in trickery and cuteness.

To keep with the topic, I want Perfume: The Story of a Murderer to be adapted by myself.

~rougerum
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: pookiethecat on October 14, 2003, 07:05:17 PM
Quote from: The Gold TrumpetTo keep with my usual self, I didn't like American Pyscho (movie) at all. The dialogue explained everything and left little mystery to anything at all the killer may have been feeling. The rationalization is that the killer and his story encompasses the feeling of spirit on modern day Wall Street in all its drive and ambition, but if gone awry. I don't see the intention for that, though. General story of man with drive and pushed to pyschosis that he kills to meet pleasures not found elsewhere. The fact that he works on Wall Street and such is only thing that is contemporary about him. And the ending, well, it gets a 10 in trickery and cuteness.

does anyone else find this paragraph incredibly incoherent?  i'm sure there are some interesting insights but i can't make sense of this paragraph.
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: Gold Trumpet on October 14, 2003, 07:09:41 PM
Quote from: pookiethecat
Quote from: The Gold TrumpetTo keep with my usual self, I didn't like American Pyscho (movie) at all. The dialogue explained everything and left little mystery to anything at all the killer may have been feeling. The rationalization is that the killer and his story encompasses the feeling of spirit on modern day Wall Street in all its drive and ambition, but if gone awry. I don't see the intention for that, though. General story of man with drive and pushed to pyschosis that he kills to meet pleasures not found elsewhere. The fact that he works on Wall Street and such is only thing that is contemporary about him. And the ending, well, it gets a 10 in trickery and cuteness.

does anyone else find this paragraph incredibly incoherent/poorly written?

Does anyone else find that responce to be demeaning and avvoiding of responce itself? I make no claim to be a good writer and considering everyone else can argue with me, I find it good enough for the message board world.

~rougerum
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: pookiethecat on October 14, 2003, 07:35:49 PM
ok in response to your post:

"The dialogue explained everything and left little mystery to anything at all the killer may have been feeling"

ok cool that makes sense. good point

"The rationalization is that the killer and his story encompasses the feeling of spirit on modern day Wall Street in all its drive and ambition, but if gone awry"

hmmm...can't say i know exactly what that means.  perhaps you're saying that the film draws a parallel between wall street brutality and violent brutality.  well to respond- that was never overt cuz there were no scenes of corporate bloodletting, so to speak.  

"General story of man with drive and pushed to pyschosis that he kills to meet pleasures not found elsewhere. The fact that he works on Wall Street and such is only thing that is contemporary about him."

say what?!  this makes no fucking sense.  

"The fact that he works on Wall Street and such is only thing that is contemporary about him"  good point but doesn't that contradict what you said earlier about violence in wall street/violence in reallife (or what i think you said).  

"And the ending, well, it gets a 10 in trickery and cuteness. "

ok, yeah, that makes sense.  valid point.  

i haven't had a problem with any of your posts in the past.  but this one was too cryptic and just nonsensicle.  and i don't think it's bad of me to call you on it.
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: Gold Trumpet on October 14, 2003, 09:13:58 PM
Quote from: pookiethecat
"The rationalization is that the killer and his story encompasses the feeling of spirit on modern day Wall Street in all its drive and ambition, but if gone awry"

hmmm...can't say i know exactly what that means.  perhaps you're saying that the film draws a parallel between wall street brutality and violent brutality.  well to respond- that was never overt cuz there were no scenes of corporate bloodletting, so to speak.

My idea was to correlate the two: Wall Street ambition in a sense being brutal and also the brutality of killing someone and what kind of drive it requires. For people who defend the purpose of this man killing, they usually give that example. That the drive of both are similiar and in this man who kills, he was bred in this world but went awry and replaces all normal pleasures with the pleasure of killing. He is that far gone from everything in his society. I disagree with that argument because nothing really is shown of him being driven by that society to kill people. At the beginning, he is already insane. Through out the movie he interacts with all the Wall Street yuppies and complains about them and then shows similiar drive in killing people. To really complicate the subject would be to show how, if he did, spring board from the world of Wall Street ambition into killing people. The movie never really does it. Its just details his actions and thoughts while being a murderer which seems to undermine the potential of the subject at hand.


Quote from: pookiethecati haven't had a problem with any of your posts in the past.  but this one was too cryptic and just nonsensicle.  and i don't think it's bad of me to call you on it.

It isn't bad to call me on it. Its bad to only reply to an argument by just calling me on my bad writing. It makes you look like what I said wasn't worth replying to. The point of my last post.

~rougerum
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: snaporaz on October 15, 2003, 04:14:55 AM
whatever you guys are saying...

i don't believe wall street or society or whatever drove him to kill. it's just that his "people", and more importantly him, are, like someone already said, so outside of our universe and so completely engulfed with bullshit that the things that really matter don't, even if it's when your friend is dragging a corpse onto a sidewalk in front of you.

but anyways, i think harron made it almost slapstick-like.

it all just seemed too colourful. too silly. i know it's supposed to be funny, but this was silly. like when that hooker was running down the halls, and that stupid music was playing. "how suspenseful". not that it should have been, but that seemed like what it was trying to accomplish, which if it did, would have been just as bad.

i did like the chase-manhattan scene, though. but i guess that's because that's only part where the atmosphere of the movie seemed appropriate.
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: coffeebeetle on October 15, 2003, 08:23:02 AM
I need another cup of coffee before I tackle this thread.  Jesus.
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: Seraphim on October 23, 2003, 08:24:44 AM
I'm going to watch American Psycho for the first time tomorrow...
don't expect to much of it, though.

What about a new version of Bright Lights, Big City?
Definitively want to see that story filmed in a good way...

Donna Tartt's The Secret History?
Although there's a big chance it would be a major disappointment.

You always have ambivalent relationship with those films based on favourite books.

You want to see your favo boo filmed, and after that you can only be irritated, annoyed, disappointed. In most cases, at least.

Soon we can "enjoy" Fishburne's version of Coelho's The Alchemist...I don't know...
Title: What Novels Would You Like To See Made Into Movies?
Post by: cine on October 23, 2003, 08:44:21 AM
My new favourite book:
(https://xixax.com/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fimages.amazon.com%2Fimages%2FP%2F1931561494.01.LZZZZZZZ.jpg&hash=123cf7dc8d77547ee41fd0d3161beadd768d0df5)