Does Over-Reliance on Pre-Visualization Kill Spontaneity in Independent Filmmaki

[nopeso]

Hello

I have noticed an increasing trend where even low-budget and indie filmmakers rely heavily on pre-visualization tools storyboard software; 3D shot planners, AI camera simulators, etc.—before ever stepping on set.    While these tools definitely help streamline production and align team vision; I've started to wonder: is this level of pre-planning possibly killing the magic of creative spontaneity, especially for directors who thrive on improvisation?

Some of the most iconic indie scenes—like Cassavetes' free-flowing dialogue or early Linklater blocking—came from instinct in the moment. With tech-driven pre-vis becoming the norm, are we unintentionally building a "safety net" that discourages on-set innovation? Or worse, are we training new directors to trust the software more than the human instinct? Checked https://xixax.com/index.php?board=15.0CISSP Course guide related to this and found it quite informative.

Would love to hear how others are balancing the need for planning with the desire to leave room for creative discovery. Do you use pre-vis religiously or only when needed? Any tools that do help encourage spontaneity rather than restrict it?






Thank you !!