Most Overrated Movie of the Year

[Satcho9]

Redirect me if this has been brought up before: But my pick for most overrated movie of the year is Minority Report.

[Xixax]

I couldn't DISagree more. Minority Report rocked.

I would get crucified if I muttered the words "Punch Drunk Love", so I will instead say something safe like "Signs".

[Cecil]

gangs of new york (juuuuuuuuuuuuuust teasing you cbrad)

[polkablues]

gangs of new york (juuuuuuuuuuuuuust teasing you cbrad)

Same answer, minus the cop-out.  And "Road to Perdition" wasn't nearly as good as I had wanted it to be (though it was still decent).

[Cecil]

cop-out? oh... me feel like a hack

[RegularKarate]

Totally going with Signs here.

Though after reading the nominations, I'd also have to say Chicago.

[MacGuffin]

Either "8 Mile" (remember all that Oscar talk for Eminem for Best Actor?) or "Lord Of The Rings: The Two Towers".

[Gold Trumpet]

Road to Perdition
Gangs of New York
Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers

~rougerum

[SHAFTR]

8 Mile

I saw it when it was called Purple Rain.

and I hate, hate, hate, hate, hate, hate, hate Eminem.

[bonanzataz]

I couldn't DISagree more. Minority Report rocked.

I would get crucified if I muttered the words "Punch Drunk Love", so I will instead say something safe like "Signs".

PDL was maybe overrated on the Cigarettes and Coffee boards, the PTAmb, and here. That's it. Anywhere else on the face of the planet, PDL was completely and totally ignored (cept for the Globes, kind of).

[Cecil]

PDL was maybe overrated

BURN HIM!!! BURN HIIIIIIIIIIM!!!!

[bonanzataz]

I said maybe, dammit! Favorite movie of the year, I saw it 4 times in theaters.

[Cecil]

say gangs or signs like the rest of us and all is forgiven

[bonanzataz]

sigh... gangs

[picolas]