I still think Punch-Drunk Love was the best DVD. LotR bores me, so I could care less about its thousands of hours of extras. And seriously, with PDL's extras, I can watch the film and the stuff over and over again and not get sick of it. That's called replay value. That's called quality. So we didn't get a commentary? Boo-hoo. I was disappointed, too, but it's not everything, and some things about certain films are left to the imagination. If PTA had at length talked about Magnolia or Punch-Drunk Love, it would definitely remove some of the mystique of those films and made them so great. PDL is the DVD that's obviously gonna get the most use from me, the most bang for my $19.95, so yeah, that's why it's the best -- if anyone was actually wondering why I was "crazy/stupid/delirious" enough to vote for it.